Are Tyler Herro Cards A Good Investment?

Tyler Herro is in his third season in the NBA. However, the 21-year-old has already seen some wild swings in card value. Therefore, many collectors are scratching their heads and wondering, are Tyler Herro cards a good investment?

In this post, we’ll take a look at Tyler Herro’s young career and where he could go from here.

Who Is Tyler Herro?

Herro was drafted in the 2019 draft as pick #13. He grew up in Milwaukee but went to college in Kentucky, where he averaged 14 points and 4.5 rebounds per game for the Wildcats during his one-and-done freshman year.

In college, he received a plethora of awards, such as:

  • Tabbed to the NCAA Tournament All-Midwest Region Team
  • Voted the Southeastern Conference Newcomer of the Year by the Associated Press
  • 2018-19 SEC Academic Honor Roll member

Despite the success, the 6’6 guard was projected to be a late lottery pick. However, the Miami Heat drafted Herro in the 2019 draft as pick #13.

You won’t find this RPA in our top 5, but its a beauty (look for National Treasures RPAs on eBay)

The First Two Years

Herro grew into his own in the second half of his rookie year, playing alongside Goran Dragic and Kendrick Nunn. He worked as a shooting guard who could occasionally handle the ball as needed.

Then, in the bubble, Herro suddenly transformed. He looked like the best rookie in a class with Ja Morant and Zion Williamson for a few games. Jimmy Butler praised the 19-year-olds poise and confidence, and it’s hard to forget Herro scorching the Celtics in Game 4 of the Eastern Conference Finals for 37 points.

And then his sophomore year came, and he underwhelmed the league. He averaged 15/5/3 – just marginally better than the 14/4/2 he averaged as a rookie. Worse still, news swirled from people close to the team that Herro didn’t have his head in the game.

Many collectors were jumping off Herro Island, and the only time you heard about Tyler was from Jack Harlow.

Year Three: The Bounce Back

Through the first ten games of the 2021-22 season, Herro looks like a legit 6th man of the year candidate. Meanwhile, the Heat are playing like a team hungry for another trip to the conference finals.

Herro is averaging 20/5/4 and has already notched a 29- and 25-point game coming off the bench.

Herro is becoming a fan favorite (look for his jerseys on eBay)

Are Tyler Herro Cards A Good Investment?

So, is this a fundamental transformation or a 10-game hot streak?

We can’t tell for sure, but I’d guess it’s the real thing – and as a friendly reminder, I watch every Heat game. Why? I am probably the team’s biggest fan in the Midwest.

Here’s why this feels real.

  • Herro was scorching hot from the get-go, leading the NBA preseason in scoring.
  • He’s a recent father and seems to be dialed in on the court with stable family life.
  • Most importantly, he is handling the ball a lot less than last year. With Lowry taking over PG duties, Herro has more time to play the role that suits him best.

I’m buying the turnaround, and I’m buying Herro cards.

The Top 5 Tyler Herro Cards

So, to answer the question: Are Tyler Herro cards a good investment? We say yes. Why? In August of 2021, Herro PSA 10 Prizm Rookies were selling for $50. Today, they’re selling for $100. That’s a 100% increase in just a couple of months, all because of Herro’s hot start.

If you want to get in on the Herro collecting before it’s too late, here’s the Cardlines Top 5 Tyler Herro cards to buy.

5. PSA 10 Prizm Rookie

Price: $100

Pop: 7,000

As just stated, this card has doubled in value over the last two months. And it’s a great low-cost entry card if you want some exposure to the Tyler Herro market without pulling out the big bucks. First, however, note the high population.

4. PSA 10 Prizm SP

Price: $125

Pop: 397

The “behind the back” short print is a great SP card with a significantly lower population than any other Prizms on the list. Therefore, it could be a very lovely pick-up for a collector working on a budget and prioritizing rarity.

The behind the back variations of Herro’s prizm have lower pop numbers (look for them on eBay)

3. PSA 10 Mosaic Silver

Price: $100

Pop: 266

The Silver is rarer than the Mosaic Silver, and this was the inaugural edition of Mosaic, so that could make it even more collectible moving forward. Plus, the $100 price tag feels undervalued compared to most other cards on this list. I like the low population, too.

2. PSA 10 Optic Holo

Price: $225

Pop: 375

The Rated Rookie holo is an excellent card at a fair price, and the low population will keep this rarer than any silver Prizm alternative.

1. PSA 10 Prizm Silver Rookie

Price: $550

Pop: 700

The Silver Prizm is the premier mass-printed (non-numbered) rookie card, so picking this card up for a reasonable price now could turn into big bucks later.

You can’t go wrong with a Silver Prizm rookie (get your Herro silvers on eBay)

Are Tyler Herro Cards A Good Investment? The Bottomline

This year, Herro is averaging 20/5/4 through 10 games.

Damien Lillard is averaging 19/7/4 through the same time.

If Herro can keep this up, he’ll be considered one of the best and could win MIP and 6th Man of the Year on a great team.

Whether or not to invest is up to you, but the trends indeed point toward a brighter future for Herro.

Jesse Haynes

Jesse Haynes

Jesse Haynes is a novelist and content writer (contentninjamarketing.com) who has played sports and collecting trading cards almost his entire life. He just graduated from the University of Tulsa with an MBA and should probably get a “real job,” but instead hopes to continue telling stories in his pajamas for a long time.